An Unspoken Art: Profiles of Veterinary Life

My greatest respect still remains with James Herriot, who intensely portrayed the image of a man who truly and absolutely loved his profession, no strings attached- one of the rare, ideal veterinary practitioners the world has yet known. However, I also respect Gutkind for his portrayal of veterinary medicine as well. His book is a realistic in-your-face reminder that you must, must properly consider all your options before committing to a career choice, because what you pursue may not be what you expected it to be.


Fascinating subject, not well presented.   August 9, 1999
L. Jack (North Carolina, USA)
6 out of 7 found this review helpful

This book is not very well written. It's unfortunate that the author finds himself in such exciting situations (a tuskectomy!) and then is unable to clearly communicate with the reader. The scope of the book is limited (a few veterinary situations, all within a convenient commute for the author) and to me (a pre-vet student) the writing is boring, stiff, and uninspiring. For those who may never get to see real-life veterinary trauma I wish there had been more than a dry book report about the procedures. Stick to James Herriot - you'll be much happier.


A somewhat disappointing view of veterinary life   January 18, 1999
2 out of 2 found this review helpful

While the author has it right when referring to veterinary medicine as an "unspoken art," the book lacks in serious impact....the first few chapters are devoted to veterinarians whose clients are wealthy New Yorkers. A turnoff for me, and worlds away from many of the "frontline" vets that I know. I appreciate his respect and admiration of the profession, but think the book could have contained more substance and stories.


A good look at contemporary veterinary life in the 90's.   December 7, 1997
This is a very interesting look at everyday veterinary life for people interested in medicine and animals. Gutkind has interesting thoughts on the comparison of human doctors to animal doctors. The book lacked the "wow" impact on the reader and that is why it is not rated "10." Since the book is written about east coast veterinarians and facilities, it would probably appeal more to easterners than us folks in the west. Overall, it is very good reading for anyone curious about veterinarians and young people wanting to go into this field.